“So, after knowing what the messenger has come with, we know by necessity that he has not legislated for his nation to call upon anyone from the dead, not the prophets, the righteous ones, or anyone other than them; not in the wording of Isthighatha or other than it, and not in the wording of Isti'anah or other than it. Just like how he has not legislated for his nation to prostrate to the dead, to one that isn't dead, or the likes of that. Rather, we know that he has forbidden us from all these affairs, and this is from amongst the Sh*rk that Allah and his messenger forbade. But due to the increase of ignorance and lack of knowledge of the Athar of the message amongst many of those who came later on, Takf*r can't be done on them until what the mesenger came with becomes clear to them from that which opposes it.” الاستغاثة ٤١١
The danger of misrepresentation and “false advertising”. The heading states “Sunni scholars Who permit instigatha” and then the first 3 (and majority) of examples you give are just STATEMENTS from these people/scholars, rather than rulings/fiqh.
If I say “I smoke cigarettes” am I permitting smoking cigarettes in Islam? No. Intellectual dishonesty at its finest. I pray Allah guides you and all of us to the correct path.
Ibn Taymiyyah says:
“So, after knowing what the messenger has come with, we know by necessity that he has not legislated for his nation to call upon anyone from the dead, not the prophets, the righteous ones, or anyone other than them; not in the wording of Isthighatha or other than it, and not in the wording of Isti'anah or other than it. Just like how he has not legislated for his nation to prostrate to the dead, to one that isn't dead, or the likes of that. Rather, we know that he has forbidden us from all these affairs, and this is from amongst the Sh*rk that Allah and his messenger forbade. But due to the increase of ignorance and lack of knowledge of the Athar of the message amongst many of those who came later on, Takf*r can't be done on them until what the mesenger came with becomes clear to them from that which opposes it.” الاستغاثة ٤١١
Only seekh help from Allah alone period!!!
If it is not in Quran then not in Islam.
Lol 😂 you write this big story and Quran destroyed by saying
Surah Al-Imran (3:173)
“Hasbunallahu wa ni’mal wakeel.”
Translation: “Sufficient for us is Allah,
Please take the Islam out of your Article..
You have written article on Sunni and Shia Religion but not Islam.
Islam is Quran period
Actually the correct translation of Quran 3:173 is “Allah is sufficient for us, and He is the best disposer of affairs”
Clearly you don’t even know how to read the Quran or English for that matter.
Quran 2:154
“Do NOT say that those martyred in the cause of Allah are dead—in fact, they are ALIVE! But you do not perceive it”
You are a Wahhabi
The danger of misrepresentation and “false advertising”. The heading states “Sunni scholars Who permit instigatha” and then the first 3 (and majority) of examples you give are just STATEMENTS from these people/scholars, rather than rulings/fiqh.
If I say “I smoke cigarettes” am I permitting smoking cigarettes in Islam? No. Intellectual dishonesty at its finest. I pray Allah guides you and all of us to the correct path.